I was made to lie to a candidate…

Man with Pinocchio nose on phone, then calls back saying "Don't take the job.

Early in my treasury recruitment career, my boss told me to lie to a candidate.

So I did.

I sat there in the office, picked up the phone and told him exactly what I’d been instructed to tell him.

It was a good job.

It was the right move for him.

The money was good.

He should take it.

But I didn’t believe a word I was saying, it was a lie.

I knew about the company and there were other reasons that made me think him taking the job was a bad idea especially as he was about to commit to his first mortgage.

And this wasn’t someone casually considering whether he fancied a change…

So this decision really mattered.

So at the end of the call, I said:

“I’ve just got a couple of other things I need to run past you… Can I call you back?”

Then I walked out of the office, got on the phone back to him and said:

“Everything I just told you was a LIE! Don’t take the job.”

The company was a massive FMCG group and I had it on extremely good authority there was a very real possibility of the business being taken over imminently.

And 3 months, that’s exactly what happened and their London offices and all their treasury operations were subsequently closed.

Had he taken that job, he’d have walked into a company, taken on a new mortgage and probably found himself looking for another job months later.

So he took my technically “unofficial” advice and turned it down.

I didn’t get my recruitment fee.

Many years later I placed him when I had started the Treasury Recruitment Company.

In fact, I went on to place him in two other jobs. And we’re still mates to this day, cheers Mark!

A few years later, somebody asked me what I thought had made me successful in recruitment.

My answer was…

If I think someone should take a job, I’ll tell them to take it.

If I think they shouldn’t, I’ll tell them not to.

Even when the second answer means I don’t get paid.

Because my job isn’t to convince every treasury professional I speak to that the vacancy sitting on my desk is the greatest opportunity they’ve ever seen.

Sometimes it isn’t.

Sometimes you’re better off staying exactly where you are.

And I’ll always be the one to tell you that.

That’s what I think a recruiter should be there for.

If all you need is someone to send you a job description and then spend three weeks persuading you to say yes, I’m not sure you’re getting much value from them.ㅤ

I’ve recruited treasury professionals for nearly 30 years now.

That means I’ve seen people make brilliant career moves, and I’ve seen people make some awful ones.ㅤ

And I’ve got a pretty good idea when something doesn’t smell right.ㅤ

So when someone comes to me about their next move, I’m not just thinking about whether I can place them into a vacancy…

I’m thinking about whether I believe it’s actually the right move for them.ㅤ

Because if I advise someone to take the wrong job just so I can collect a fee…

They probably won’t trust me with the next one.

Best regards,

Mike

Related articles